I Just Had a Supernatural Experience

Spoiler: not really.

I was just in the kitchen fixing dinner for the cats, when I heard a woman cough. Just a single throat-clearing cough. It definitely sounded like a woman.

And this was odd, since there aren’t supposed to be any women in the house. Any company would be unexpected, seeing as how I’m snowed in by Snowmageddon. But it was convincing enough that I checked the living room and looked for fresh tracks in the snow outside. Perhaps someone got stranded and wandered in when she found an accidentally-unlocked door? Or could it be a ghost?

Obviously, there was no one there, as you know, since you’ve read the spoiler at the top. I tried replaying the sound on the tape recorder of my mind[1] and play it back, trying to figure out what I’d heard, rather than what I thought I’d heard. That is, I asked myself what sounds I might mistake for a woman’s cough.

The most likely candidate I came up with is a chair leg creaking across the wooden floor. This is consistent with one of the cats jumping off of the chair to get his dinner, especially since there’s a chair that he particularly likes to lie on. I don’t know that that’s what happened, of course, but it makes a heck of a lot more sense than ghosts. (Besides, $CAT sashayed into the kitchen with his tail held high, and not at all as if he’d seen a ghost.)

At any rate, this illustrates why one should be skeptical about reports of UFOs, the paranormal, etc. When someone says “I saw X”, usually what they mean is “I saw something that I interpreted as X”. Yes, they’re sincere, but it’s quite possible for people to be sincerely mistaken. And unfortunately, it’s not possible to reach into people’s heads and pull out what they actually saw or heard, as opposed to what they say they saw or heard. Which means that oral testimony, however sincere, isn’t sufficient to prove the existence of UFOs or paranormal phenoma. As the kids say, “Pics or it didn’t happen.”

(HT to Anne for the meteorologist video.)

(Cross-posted at UMD Society of Inquiry.)


[1] Note to young people: in ancient times, a tape recorder was a device that recorded sounds so you could play them back later. They were very good at playing back ambient sounds. So if you recorded an interview with someone and played it back, you’d hear the creaking of your chair with perfect such clarity that it would drown out the interviewee.

This entry was posted in Skepticism and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to I Just Had a Supernatural Experience

  1. menes777 says:

    Isn’t it obvious??? Cats devoted themselves to the devil centuries ago and that’s why they are cursed to make coughing sounds like a woman!

    Like

  2. Fez says:

    How might that hypothesis explain horses? Their cough sound identical to a human male. Really freakin’ unnerving when you’re certain you should be the only human in the barn.

    Like

  3. arensb says:

    Maybe that’s why cats and horses get along so well.

    Like

  4. menes777 says:

    The connection is in the name, Felines and Equines. Both are devil spawn and the global flood can clearly explains that’s how god intended it to happen. 🙂

    Like

  5. arensb says:

    That’s byzantine and asinine. Maybe you should cut down on the caffeine.

    Like

  6. menes777 says:

    *Throws hands up in the air* There’s no sense talking here, since ya’ll aren’t Chriss-chuns you wouldn’t understand these things.

    🙂

    Like

  7. menes777 says:

    [/ flabber impersonation]

    Like

  8. arensb says:

    [/ flabber impersonation]

    Will you send me money first?

    Like

  9. menes777 says:

    Just invite taps over to investigate your “cough” and then make your own spin-off show inserting the word ghost somewhere in the title. Instant profits!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s